We talked in class about the portrayal of various characters from Mrs. Dalloway in the movie "The Hours." There are a lot of characters who could potentially be Richard Brown, the suicidal writer from the movie. It is only natural to immediately assosicate him with Septimus who is also a suicidal writer who experiences hallucinations and heras voices. They both had traumatizing pasts, Septimus experiencing the war first-hand and Richard being deserted by his mother at a young age, and the ghosts of their pasts still haunt them.
However, another one of my earlier ideas was that Richard could be Peter Walsh because he and Clarissa had a previous romantic relathionship. Upon closer inspection, I changed my mind and decided Richard was more like Sally Seaton. In Mrs. Dalloway, we learn about when Sally and Clariss shared a kiss in their youth, and how that kiss still lingers in Clarissa's mind. However, they both ended up marrying men rather than exploring the possibility of being with someone of the same gender. Similarly, the Clarissa and the Richard from "The Hours" had a spark between them years ago, and they also ended up having different sexual orientations, shown by Clarissa being with Sally and Richard's previous relationship with Luis Waters.
One thing that is different, however, about Richard Brown and Sally Seaton is that Richard still thinks about his past romance with Clarissa Vaughan, even in the last moments of his life, while, to the best of our knowledge, Sally did not dwell on her romance with Clarissa Dalloway. This aspect proposes the idea that Clarissa Dalloway and Richard Brown are more similar than it originally seems. Clarissa and Richard both are haunted by the past, and Clarissa was supposed to kill herself before the Septimus character was brought into Mrs. Dalloway. Perhaps this is a way to portray a version of the novel where Clarissa does, in fact, commit suicide.
So who is Richard Brown? Is he Peter Walsh? Is he Sally Seaton? It is hard to tell, but I would say that he is a mixture of many main characters from the book, maybe even a character smoothie. He is involved in two of the three stories that "The Hours" follows and the reason for that is because he is such an important combination of people.
Wednesday, September 25, 2013
Thursday, September 19, 2013
Throwback Thursday
Often times, people form ideas and views of other people, places, and events that they have experienced in their lives. It can be very hard to accept that things, or sometimes one's self, are different, so people usually have a tough time coping. Richard had not seen Clarissa for some time before the beginning of Mrs. Dalloway, his only communication with her being letters sent between England and India. When Peter returns to London and visits Clarissa, they both have the realization that things have changed over the years since they last were together. Peter tries to hold on to his memory of the past, but at the same time he becomes more restless as he realizes that the present is different from the past.
"Here she is mending her dress; mending her dress as usual, he thought; here she's been sitting all the time I've been in India; mending her dress; playing about; going to parties; running to the House and back and all that, he thought, growing more and more irritated, more and more agitated," (40).
Peter has trouble with the recognition of change, not with Clarissa, but with himself. In Clarissa's eyes, Peter is still the same man she knew before he went to India -- playing with his pocket-knife, having a love affair with a younger woman -- but Peter thinks the contrary, that he has not remained the same, while Clarissa is stuck in the exact same life as before he left. This meeting is troublesome for both Clarissa and Peter because they both have been so occupied with the past and their notions of each other from their days in Bourton. This consumes their thoughts for the rest of the novel, the comparison of their former selves and their present selves, and it provides for tensions between them. Whether it is seeing someone from years ago or returning to a town you used to live in, it is always hard to grasp and accept that the present is not the same as the past and that over time things change.
"Here she is mending her dress; mending her dress as usual, he thought; here she's been sitting all the time I've been in India; mending her dress; playing about; going to parties; running to the House and back and all that, he thought, growing more and more irritated, more and more agitated," (40).
Peter has trouble with the recognition of change, not with Clarissa, but with himself. In Clarissa's eyes, Peter is still the same man she knew before he went to India -- playing with his pocket-knife, having a love affair with a younger woman -- but Peter thinks the contrary, that he has not remained the same, while Clarissa is stuck in the exact same life as before he left. This meeting is troublesome for both Clarissa and Peter because they both have been so occupied with the past and their notions of each other from their days in Bourton. This consumes their thoughts for the rest of the novel, the comparison of their former selves and their present selves, and it provides for tensions between them. Whether it is seeing someone from years ago or returning to a town you used to live in, it is always hard to grasp and accept that the present is not the same as the past and that over time things change.
Sunday, September 8, 2013
Septimus vs. Clarissa
When first pondering the question "Are Clarissa and Septimus alike?" the immediate answer that pops into my mind is that they are very different. But, while that is a true fact on a very basic, obvious, external level, it is untrue when you probe deeper into each of the characters.
The majority of human beings want to find their places in the world (pardon my cheesiness), so we often restrain ourselves to come across as more likeable, and Clarissa is a perfect example of this. At the begining of the book, when the motor car passes by, she tries to keep herself composed, in case the rider of the car looks out at her. At the same time, Septimus is concerned about blocking the way and making the other pedestrians and drivers unhappy. They are portray different emotions on their faces and their minds are worrying over completely different things, yet they are both anxious over how other people view them.
It was mentioned in class last week that Septimus was paranoid and aprehensive, most likely due to the trauma within him caused by the war. But Clarissa also had a sort of war in her own past, a war with herself about love. She had to make a difficult decision between Richard Dalloway and Peter Walsh, and during that time she suffered a great deal of criticism from Peter. It scarred her and that is why she, too, is paranoid about how she comes across to other people.
Both Clarissa and Septimus had traumas in their pasts that still haunt them on the day the book takes place. While Septiumus's psycological damage could be considered more serious than Clarissa's, that doesn't change the fact that they are much more similar to each other than they appear to be on the outside.
The majority of human beings want to find their places in the world (pardon my cheesiness), so we often restrain ourselves to come across as more likeable, and Clarissa is a perfect example of this. At the begining of the book, when the motor car passes by, she tries to keep herself composed, in case the rider of the car looks out at her. At the same time, Septimus is concerned about blocking the way and making the other pedestrians and drivers unhappy. They are portray different emotions on their faces and their minds are worrying over completely different things, yet they are both anxious over how other people view them.
It was mentioned in class last week that Septimus was paranoid and aprehensive, most likely due to the trauma within him caused by the war. But Clarissa also had a sort of war in her own past, a war with herself about love. She had to make a difficult decision between Richard Dalloway and Peter Walsh, and during that time she suffered a great deal of criticism from Peter. It scarred her and that is why she, too, is paranoid about how she comes across to other people.
Both Clarissa and Septimus had traumas in their pasts that still haunt them on the day the book takes place. While Septiumus's psycological damage could be considered more serious than Clarissa's, that doesn't change the fact that they are much more similar to each other than they appear to be on the outside.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)