Thursday, December 12, 2013

Close One Door, Open Another

Before reading chapter 9 of Song of Solomon, neither of Milkman's sisters had very prominent parts in the novel's plotline. However, in this chapter, not only did information came to light about Corinthians's relationship with Porter and how she fit into the story, but the reader was also introduced to Lena. Her love for her sister mixes with her disguist towards her brother and her father as she chews out Milkman for ratting out Corinthians and Porter to Macon Jr. At the end of her lecture, Milkman leaves her room, wondering, "why not take" Lena's "good advice" to stop being lazy and leave, so he closes the door and does exactly that at the beginning of Part 2 (216).
When the narrator tells us that Milkman closes the door, it is not only in a physical sense, but also in a symbolic sense. Milkman closes the door on his past where he plays the part of a lazy, immature, teenager-like man who is completely dependent on his parents and opens the door to his future where he can strive to play the part of a mature, independent man who is in control of his life. In her rant, Lena compares Milkman to his parents, even saying he is just like Macon Jr. Milkman brushes off all of her accusations through sarcasm, but her words really do hit the spot and Milkman feels motivated to step out of his father's shadow. He lives with his parents and has been employed by his father since he was a teenager. However, in Part 2 is goes on a more in depth search for the gold that his father has been hoping to find for decades, proving that he has taken matters into his own hands. Milkman shows that he will no longer be lazy by putting in the effort to travel to another state and search through the woods to find the cave that is the supposed location of the gold. He treks through mud, ruining his clothes, feeling hunger pains, and stepping outside his comfort zone altogether. Milkman's journey to find the gold becomes not so much to find the monetary treasure as it is to find his identity and to grow as a person. He must experience more of the world before he can be considered a mature adult and Lena's talk with him gives him the push he needed to open the door to acheiving adulthood.

Friday, December 6, 2013

Wide Sargasso Sea vs. Song of Solomon

Although we are less than halfway into Toni Morrison's Song of Solomon, I can't help but feel more interested in this book than I was in Wide Sargasso Sea. Upon having this realization, I decided to investigate as to why I didn't enjoy Wide Sargasso Sea very much. Was it the narrative style? Was it the plotline? Or was it the characters? My theory is that the people in Wide Sargasso Sea had a big role in my lack of interest in the novel, whereas the cast of characters in Song of Solomon aid in my enjoyment of the book.
In both of these novels there are hierarchical relationships between the characters, such as a man (Rochester and Macon Dead) treating his wife (Antoinette and Ruth) as inferior to him. In both of these instances, I initially sympathized with the wives, believing that they were the victims and their husbands were in the wrong for treating them badly. This idea came to light in Wide Sargasso Sea through Rochester's surpression of Antoinette, as well as his adulterous ways. Rhys introduces the reader to Antoinette from early on and we see all the struggles she goes through, so we become sympathetic towards her and dislike Rochester for treating her poorly. However, after progressing further into Song of Solomon, I've come to have a different opinion of Macon Dead's treatment of Ruth. Macon seems at first to pick on his wife without reason and he comes across as a jerk, but as the story goes on and new information is revealed, the reader learns that Ruth has incestual tendencies that are understandably upseting to her husband. I don't believe in the merit of spouse abuse, so I don't feel that it is fair of Macon Dead to hit his wife, but I have grown more sympathetic towards him and I don't think that his wife is innocent. Unlike in the case of Rochester's mistreatment of innocent Antoinette, there isn't a set victim or villian between Macon Dead and Ruth, so I feel no strong dislike towards one character that can cloud my enjoyment of the story.
Despite my dislike for one of the central characters of Wide Sargasso Sea, Rochester, I particularly enjoyed the character of Christophine. She was loyal and loving towards Antoinette, cool, bold, and witty towards Rochester, and an overall likeable person with spunk and care for others. As I read Song of Solomon, I'm reminded of her when I read about Pilate, Macon Dead's sister. They both are unique and a bit different from the other characters, with loyalties to specific characters. Pilate is loyal to her brother while Christophine is loyal to Antoinette. In my mind I made a connection between Antoinette and Macon Dead because of their relationships with Christophine and Pilate, respectively. Due to my fondness of Antoinette and Christophine, I've developed new appreciation for Macon Dead and that is helping me enjoy Song of Solomon more.
While I did not enjoy Wide Sargasso Sea very much, largely due to the cast of characters the novel had, comparing it to Song of Solomon is in fact helping me take more pleasure in this story.

Wednesday, November 13, 2013

The Irrationality of the Universe

The Stranger by Albert Camus is a provocative novel with two of its major themes being the absurdity of the world and the meaninglessness of human life. Both of these themes manifest themselves when the novel's main character, Meursault, is alone in his prison cell waiting to be executed for killing an innocent man. He expresses fear for the first time when his heart beat "leaps" as he thinks about his imminent death. However, soon after Meursault opens up to the reader, he ponders the following question: If you're going to die, what's it matter if it is now or in 20 years? This seems to help him calm down a bit but I found this part to the be the most disturbing passage in the book.
Meursault had some low moments in terms of his humanity (i.e. killing the Arab, failing to show grief at his mother's funeral, etc.) but the hopeless approach that he takes in dealing with death sentence takes the cake. With the other instances of Meursault's lack of compassion, I found that, as an optimistic person, I could form little excuses as to why he should be forgiven. However, when he started having depressing thoughts about the lack of meaning of human life, I became both sad for and angry at him. I was angry at him because I felt like he wasn't aware of the privelage that he had in his life and because he didn't seize the opportunities for a better life that were handed to him, such as marrying Marie. But then I realized that, in my opinion, life is worth living if you have goals and aspirations, something to work towards (sorry if this is really cheesy), and Meursault did not have any of those. This was where I became sad for him. He had dreams once upon a time but he decided that they were irrational and adopted this attitude that life isn't worth living.
I guess this part of the book unnerved me because I couldn't imagine how Meursault was feeling or why he was feeling that way. Camus's way of working the two ideas -- the absurdity of the world and the meaninglessness of human life -- into The Stranger really got under my skin and I haven't decided yet if I liked the provocation or not.

Sunday, November 3, 2013

She Likes Me, She Likes Me Not

Now that I have finished The Stranger, I feel as though I should be able to say whether or not I like Meursault. However, I do not have a clearly formed opinion of the man because I have conflicting ideas about his personality. "First impressions are the most lasting." That is a saying that applies here because I can't get my initial reaction to Meursault out of my mind. At the beginning of the book I tried to read with an open mind and search for subtle clues that Meursault was actually grieving his mother's death. Instead, I was surprised at his lack of concern for which day his mother died and his worry over making his boss unhappy for requesting a couple of days off of work to go to the funeral. As I read on, I discovered that Meursault did not feel bad about not visiting his mother while she was still alive because it would have cost him time, money, and effort. The last straw for me was when Meursault expressed irritation with the people from the retirement home, remarking sarcastically, "they all shook my hand -- as if that night during which we hadn't exchanged as much as a single word had somehow brought us closer together," (12).
For almost the entire book I carried this notion that Meursault was an unsympathetic jerk who lacked any kind of emotion; I even agreed a bit when the prosecutor claimed that he "didn't have a soul and that nothing human" was within his reach (101). However, during that very scene when his trial was being wrapped up, I began to feel pity for him. I allowed myself to have sympathy for him because I noticed that he seemed to finally be expressing some emotion that was not irritation -- the only feeling that I had noticed from him up until that point. Meursault expresses feelings of nostalgia, saying,
"I was assailed by memories of a life that wasn't mine anymore, but one in which I'd found the simplest and most lasting of joys: the smells of summer, the part of town I loved, a certain evening sky, Marie's dresses and the way she laughed," (104).
When I read that, an idea hit me: Meursault is scared that he will die and lose the life that he is actually happy with. This realization evoked a stronger feeling of empathy for him and his predicament, especially when he used words such as "strange" and "bizarre" when talking about recieving his death sentence. They also showed that he was afraid and that is a very human emotion that is easy to identify with.
The war going on inside of me about how I should feel towards Meursault is still going strong. My first impression that Meursault is basically a psychopath remains burned in my brain, but there is also the newer idea that he actually does have some emotion, he just keeps it hidden. I guess I kind of see him as two different people, one who is normal and who I like, and one who isn't normal and who I don't like.

Wednesday, October 16, 2013

Involuntary Shudders

In Kafka's The Metamorphosis, the main character turns into a giant bug. The way that the story is narrated does not imply that there is anything wrong at all with this occurrence, which is sort of odd. This fact is established in the first sentence and Gregor Samsa does not seem very preoccupied with his new body as the book progresses. The fact that Samsa isn't troubled by it at all makes me feel a bit uncomfortable, like maybe there is something wrong with him. After it is established that he has become a "monstrous vermin" the narrator goes on to describe what his body looks like, including the frantically flailing legs (I gave an involuntary shudder when I read over the description in the book just now). The reader can picture quite easily what it would be like to look down at your self and see a large bug's body. The combination of this view and Samsa's lack of reaction (I can imagine that I would be screaming if this happened to me) also make me feel uncomfortable. As the book progresses and Samsa starts to embrace his life as a bug more and more, my unease also grows. His diet for rotting food as well as his worsening sight slightly scared and worried me.
Aside from the obvious, bug-related things, this book makes me uncomfortable because of the way Samsa respects his father and himself. While he has what could be considered too much respect for his father, he has too little respect for himself. Samsa accepts the life of servitude to pay for his parents' debt and takes on the responsability of the father figure while the father only sits at home and eats breakfast or reads the newspaper. His life consists only of going to work, never leaving any leisure time, a worry that his parents express unconvincingly. Samsa is subservient to both his parents and his manager and his failure to stand up for himself really irritates me, as well as makes me feel uncomfortable. Even when Samsa comes out of his room and tries to defend himself against the manager's claims of laziness and theivery, he puts himself down to appeal for forgiveness.
The combination of Samsa's complient personality and his recent change of physique are enough to leave anyone weary. While I appreciate the skill of Franz Kafka's writing in this novel, and it has to be good if it is making me feel this way, but I can't say that The Metamorphosis is a book that I like. But I haven't finished it yet, so maybe I'll change my mind.

Thursday, October 10, 2013

The Green Light Also Rises

Last week, Katherine and I were talking about The Sun Also Rises and she brought up the idea that it is similar to The Great Gatsby, which I thought was very interesting. There are obvious differences in the plots of these two stories, seeing as how they are independent novels of each other, but there are underlying themes that they have in common.
One of these similarities is the idea of a tragic love story. Both Daisy and Brett are spirited women who demand a lot of attention and who are at the center of these love stories. Their husbands, Tom and Mike, can both be aggressive drunks who can't stop their wives from being interested in other men. Gatsby and Jake are alike in that they love women who they can't be with. Gatsby and Daisy can't be together because she is too attached to her life with Tom, causing her to lead Gatsby on and toy with his emotions. Brett and Jake can't be together either because she is not willing to sacrifice the sexual aspect of a relationship that Jake cannot provide due to his injury. These stories are tragic because the people in love can't be together, but they are also irritating because they seem to go nowhere. At the end of each novel, despite all the drama that has gone on before it regarding the love stories, they are back to square one and nothing has been accomplished or changed.
Another common theme in The Great Gatsby and The Sun Also Rises is the partying and drinking. It is true that the drinking is more prevalent in The Sun Also Rises while the parties play a larger role in The Great Gatsby, but I would say that they go hand in hand. The festivities are the center of the social scene in both novels, and because the relationships between the characters is such a vital part of the storties, it is important to pay attention those parts. Jake and Gatsby both interact in these partying scenes in a remote way, often seeming to be observing rather than taking part in them. The detached way that they act in larger groups combined with their interactions with Brett and Daisy show that they are very similar characters.
The behaviour of the characters as well as the relationships between them show that even though the plots may differ, The Great Gatsby and The Sun Also Rises have a lot in common. Maybe it is because the authors were such great friends, maybe it was because they were written around the same time, or maybe it was a combination of these influences. Whatever the reason, there is no denying that these two novels are not as different as they first seem to be.

Wednesday, September 25, 2013

A Character Smoothie

We talked in class about the portrayal of various characters from Mrs. Dalloway in the movie "The Hours." There are a lot of characters who could potentially be Richard Brown, the suicidal writer from the movie. It is only natural to immediately assosicate him with Septimus who is also a suicidal writer who experiences hallucinations and heras voices. They both had traumatizing pasts, Septimus experiencing the war first-hand and Richard being deserted by his mother at a young age, and the ghosts of their pasts still haunt them.
However, another one of my earlier ideas was that Richard could be Peter Walsh because he and Clarissa had a previous romantic relathionship. Upon closer inspection, I changed my mind and decided Richard was more like Sally Seaton. In Mrs. Dalloway, we learn about when Sally and Clariss shared a kiss in their youth, and how that kiss still lingers in Clarissa's mind. However, they both ended up marrying men rather than exploring the possibility of being with someone of the same gender. Similarly, the Clarissa and the Richard from "The Hours" had a spark between them years ago, and they also ended up having different sexual orientations, shown by Clarissa being with Sally and Richard's previous relationship with Luis Waters.
One thing that is different, however, about Richard Brown and Sally Seaton is that Richard still thinks about his past romance with Clarissa Vaughan, even in the last moments of his life, while, to the best of our knowledge, Sally did not dwell on her romance with Clarissa Dalloway. This aspect proposes the idea that Clarissa Dalloway and Richard Brown are more similar than it originally seems. Clarissa and Richard both are haunted by the past, and Clarissa was supposed to kill herself before the Septimus character was brought into Mrs. Dalloway. Perhaps this is a way to portray a version of the novel where Clarissa does, in fact, commit suicide.
So who is Richard Brown? Is he Peter Walsh? Is he Sally Seaton? It is hard to tell, but I would say that he is a mixture of many main characters from the book, maybe even a character smoothie. He is involved in two of the three stories that "The Hours" follows and the reason for that is because he is such an important combination of people.