When first pondering the question "Are Clarissa and Septimus alike?" the immediate answer that pops into my mind is that they are very different. But, while that is a true fact on a very basic, obvious, external level, it is untrue when you probe deeper into each of the characters.
The majority of human beings want to find their places in the world (pardon my cheesiness), so we often restrain ourselves to come across as more likeable, and Clarissa is a perfect example of this. At the begining of the book, when the motor car passes by, she tries to keep herself composed, in case the rider of the car looks out at her. At the same time, Septimus is concerned about blocking the way and making the other pedestrians and drivers unhappy. They are portray different emotions on their faces and their minds are worrying over completely different things, yet they are both anxious over how other people view them.
It was mentioned in class last week that Septimus was paranoid and aprehensive, most likely due to the trauma within him caused by the war. But Clarissa also had a sort of war in her own past, a war with herself about love. She had to make a difficult decision between Richard Dalloway and Peter Walsh, and during that time she suffered a great deal of criticism from Peter. It scarred her and that is why she, too, is paranoid about how she comes across to other people.
Both Clarissa and Septimus had traumas in their pasts that still haunt them on the day the book takes place. While Septiumus's psycological damage could be considered more serious than Clarissa's, that doesn't change the fact that they are much more similar to each other than they appear to be on the outside.
This is an idea I've also considered-- their similarities. Clarissa and Septimus both look rather nondescript from to outside but contain inner turmoil and are absorbed in different realities than the "real world"; Clarissa with the past and Septimus with his visions. All in all, I think this is a very interesting idea and I completely agree that Septimus' greater trauma shouldn't somehow erase or trivialize Clarissa's.
ReplyDeleteI think this is pretty interesting, considering I had typically thought the exact opposite the whole time I was reading the novel. I took Clarissa as someone that had a very separated life: her private face, public face, Peter face, Richard face, Elizabeth face, Miss Kilman face, and so on, while Septimus just had a jumble of thoughts-- he doesn't even make the distinction between the past and the present at times! I think it's interesting that you compare their pasts, and now looking at it I can recognize that they are pretty similar, but even though they were somewhat similar, they handled them in their own respective ways (Septimus went crazy, Clarissa remained calm). I think it's kind of cool to compare and contrast them to see how they each reacted differently to comparable events in their lives.
ReplyDeleteWhen considering Clarissa and trauma, of course, we should also keep in mind the fact that she witnessed, apparently first-hand, her sister being killed by a falling tree. We learn this through Peter, significantly, not Clarissa herself--she never thinks about it explicitly on this June day. But it establishes an important, not immediately visible line of connection between these two characters.
ReplyDeleteMaya makes an excellent point: there are a range of surprising underlying connections between them, but the surface-level differences are also significant. For whatever reason, Clarissa has been able to maintain a highly successful façade of a "normal," functional person in society, even if this means that her "depth" isn't always evident to others. (Part of the risk of this "hostess" persona, it seems, is that people assume Clarissa is kind of an intellectual lightweight. She's more or less okay with this, though it bugs her that she's always underestimated by others.) In contrast, Septimus's "depth" is *so* on the surface that no one has any idea what he's talking about.