Last week, Katherine and I were talking about The Sun Also Rises and she brought up the idea that it is similar to The Great Gatsby, which I thought was very interesting. There are obvious differences in the plots of these two stories, seeing as how they are independent novels of each other, but there are underlying themes that they have in common.
One of these similarities is the idea of a tragic love story. Both Daisy and Brett are spirited women who demand a lot of attention and who are at the center of these love stories. Their husbands, Tom and Mike, can both be aggressive drunks who can't stop their wives from being interested in other men. Gatsby and Jake are alike in that they love women who they can't be with. Gatsby and Daisy can't be together because she is too attached to her life with Tom, causing her to lead Gatsby on and toy with his emotions. Brett and Jake can't be together either because she is not willing to sacrifice the sexual aspect of a relationship that Jake cannot provide due to his injury. These stories are tragic because the people in love can't be together, but they are also irritating because they seem to go nowhere. At the end of each novel, despite all the drama that has gone on before it regarding the love stories, they are back to square one and nothing has been accomplished or changed.
Another common theme in The Great Gatsby and The Sun Also Rises is the partying and drinking. It is true that the drinking is more prevalent in The Sun Also Rises while the parties play a larger role in The Great Gatsby, but I would say that they go hand in hand. The festivities are the center of the social scene in both novels, and because the relationships between the characters is such a vital part of the storties, it is important to pay attention those parts. Jake and Gatsby both interact in these partying scenes in a remote way, often seeming to be observing rather than taking part in them. The detached way that they act in larger groups combined with their interactions with Brett and Daisy show that they are very similar characters.
The behaviour of the characters as well as the relationships between them show that even though the plots may differ, The Great Gatsby and The Sun Also Rises have a lot in common. Maybe it is because the authors were such great friends, maybe it was because they were written around the same time, or maybe it was a combination of these influences. Whatever the reason, there is no denying that these two novels are not as different as they first seem to be.
Wow, now that you point them out, I can really see how similar the two books are! I think that even location seems to play a role, as they are both set in big, blooming cities, as well as time they are set in, because they are both in the post-World War I period.
ReplyDeleteGoing along with the partying and drinking that you mentioned, another similarity is the decadent and carefree lifestyle that characters in both novels seem to lead. In Great Gatsby, work is basically never mentioned for the characters who do work (Nick) and half the characters are rich enough that they don't need to (for example, Gatsby). Likewise, work seems to be just a thought in the back of the character's minds in the Sun Also Rises rather than something to be taken seriously.
I would say that the personality of Jake is more like Nick Carraway's than Jay Gatsby's. Nick is the narrator of the story, and I feel like his calm and thoughtful (but slightly judgemental and sarcastic) voice is similar to Jake. Both Nick and Jake seem separated from the stories they are telling--it's like they're sitting there quietly watching the drama unfold in front of them. Neither Nick or Jake say very much to the other characters, but instead are confidants for many characters (Jake for Brett, and Cohn; Nick for Gatsby and Daisy).
ReplyDeleteAs for the romance in the stories, Nick brings Gatsby and Daisy together again at a tea party at his house. Jake also plays this role a bit when he sets Brett up with Romero at the bar in Spain.
This is indeed a rich and insightful comparison (and I did mention in class that Fitzgerald played a significant role in editing Hemingway's novel--it was his suggestion to start with the paragraph about Cohn, which had initially appeared later in the narrative).
ReplyDeleteOne thing that's ironic about both of these novels is that they're heralded as celebrating the "jazz age" ("Roaring 20s", whatever), and in the popular imagination are often associated with images of carefree young people drinking and dancing the night away. A careful reading of both, however, reveals (as you point out) a less sanguine picture, including the emotional collateral damage wrought by such a decadent social scene. Both novels have a tinge of nostalgia for the prewar world and a sense that culture is maybe not moving in the most promising direction. They are "lost generation" novels, but they both approach that generation with a surprising sobriety.
I really agree that The Sun Also Rises is in many ways similar to The Great Gatsby, and also feels similar to another book I've read by F. Scott Fitzgerald, This Side of Paradise. One of the first things I noticed that was similar to This Side of Paradise was the drinking. There's a lot of that. And with the drinking comes lost love and depression. Although This Side of Paradise doesn't necessarily have the voice of Hemingway, there are still some parts that share ideas with The Sun Also Rises. The last line is "'I know myself,' he cried,'but that is all--'" which really brings back the whole idea of being lost in a new world as a member of the lost generation.
ReplyDelete