Sunday, November 3, 2013

She Likes Me, She Likes Me Not

Now that I have finished The Stranger, I feel as though I should be able to say whether or not I like Meursault. However, I do not have a clearly formed opinion of the man because I have conflicting ideas about his personality. "First impressions are the most lasting." That is a saying that applies here because I can't get my initial reaction to Meursault out of my mind. At the beginning of the book I tried to read with an open mind and search for subtle clues that Meursault was actually grieving his mother's death. Instead, I was surprised at his lack of concern for which day his mother died and his worry over making his boss unhappy for requesting a couple of days off of work to go to the funeral. As I read on, I discovered that Meursault did not feel bad about not visiting his mother while she was still alive because it would have cost him time, money, and effort. The last straw for me was when Meursault expressed irritation with the people from the retirement home, remarking sarcastically, "they all shook my hand -- as if that night during which we hadn't exchanged as much as a single word had somehow brought us closer together," (12).
For almost the entire book I carried this notion that Meursault was an unsympathetic jerk who lacked any kind of emotion; I even agreed a bit when the prosecutor claimed that he "didn't have a soul and that nothing human" was within his reach (101). However, during that very scene when his trial was being wrapped up, I began to feel pity for him. I allowed myself to have sympathy for him because I noticed that he seemed to finally be expressing some emotion that was not irritation -- the only feeling that I had noticed from him up until that point. Meursault expresses feelings of nostalgia, saying,
"I was assailed by memories of a life that wasn't mine anymore, but one in which I'd found the simplest and most lasting of joys: the smells of summer, the part of town I loved, a certain evening sky, Marie's dresses and the way she laughed," (104).
When I read that, an idea hit me: Meursault is scared that he will die and lose the life that he is actually happy with. This realization evoked a stronger feeling of empathy for him and his predicament, especially when he used words such as "strange" and "bizarre" when talking about recieving his death sentence. They also showed that he was afraid and that is a very human emotion that is easy to identify with.
The war going on inside of me about how I should feel towards Meursault is still going strong. My first impression that Meursault is basically a psychopath remains burned in my brain, but there is also the newer idea that he actually does have some emotion, he just keeps it hidden. I guess I kind of see him as two different people, one who is normal and who I like, and one who isn't normal and who I don't like.

2 comments:

  1. I would say that's probably one intention of Camus, to create a character that deeply challenges our belief in humanity. It's easy with some characters because they are static in their lack of humanity. Meursault isn't, he certainly has very human emotions and issues at times, yet at other times seems otherworldly. Even Meursault is unsure of how he wants people (implicitly us) to view him, at times wanting to cry because he can feel the hatred and at other times reveling and craving the hatred he expects to be coming. One early character trait that I saw of his that was perhaps endearing was his second-guessing nature, how he'd say something to his boss and then immediately berate himself for saying it. It may not be an emotion, but it is certainly something I can identify with, and I would imagine most readers could too.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I agree with this idea completely, and my blog post is somewhat along these lines as well. While reading the novel my ideas of Meursault continued to change from better, to worse, and to better again. Camus introduces us to a character that is indifferent, and when we see his indifference in different scenarios, we as readers develop an emotion towards him based off of our own beliefs. This simulates the trial scene, as the jury is judging Meursault off of what they think is right, but they also judge his indifferent personality with various situations to back up their judgements on him. This idea kind of reminds me of when we read The Mezzanine when Howie refers to inspecting something against a clear background. The garbage truck to him seemed so different against the clear blue sky-- he was able to understand the different intricacies of it. When we see Meursault's indifference against various backgrounds, we feel differently towards him, especially since his actions are so unorthodox. The trial can't just judge Meursault's crime, but they can't just judge his indifference because both are seen in different ways. Due to his confusing personality, everyone has trouble understanding how he should be perceived.

    ReplyDelete