Although we are less than halfway into Toni Morrison's Song of Solomon, I can't help but feel more interested in this book than I was in Wide Sargasso Sea. Upon having this realization, I decided to investigate as to why I didn't enjoy Wide Sargasso Sea very much. Was it the narrative style? Was it the plotline? Or was it the characters? My theory is that the people in Wide Sargasso Sea had a big role in my lack of interest in the novel, whereas the cast of characters in Song of Solomon aid in my enjoyment of the book.
In both of these novels there are hierarchical relationships between the characters, such as a man (Rochester and Macon Dead) treating his wife (Antoinette and Ruth) as inferior to him. In both of these instances, I initially sympathized with the wives, believing that they were the victims and their husbands were in the wrong for treating them badly. This idea came to light in Wide Sargasso Sea through Rochester's surpression of Antoinette, as well as his adulterous ways. Rhys introduces the reader to Antoinette from early on and we see all the struggles she goes through, so we become sympathetic towards her and dislike Rochester for treating her poorly. However, after progressing further into Song of Solomon, I've come to have a different opinion of Macon Dead's treatment of Ruth. Macon seems at first to pick on his wife without reason and he comes across as a jerk, but as the story goes on and new information is revealed, the reader learns that Ruth has incestual tendencies that are understandably upseting to her husband. I don't believe in the merit of spouse abuse, so I don't feel that it is fair of Macon Dead to hit his wife, but I have grown more sympathetic towards him and I don't think that his wife is innocent. Unlike in the case of Rochester's mistreatment of innocent Antoinette, there isn't a set victim or villian between Macon Dead and Ruth, so I feel no strong dislike towards one character that can cloud my enjoyment of the story.
Despite my dislike for one of the central characters of Wide Sargasso Sea, Rochester, I particularly enjoyed the character of Christophine. She was loyal and loving towards Antoinette, cool, bold, and witty towards Rochester, and an overall likeable person with spunk and care for others. As I read Song of Solomon, I'm reminded of her when I read about Pilate, Macon Dead's sister. They both are unique and a bit different from the other characters, with loyalties to specific characters. Pilate is loyal to her brother while Christophine is loyal to Antoinette. In my mind I made a connection between Antoinette and Macon Dead because of their relationships with Christophine and Pilate, respectively. Due to my fondness of Antoinette and Christophine, I've developed new appreciation for Macon Dead and that is helping me enjoy Song of Solomon more.
While I did not enjoy Wide Sargasso Sea very much, largely due to the cast of characters the novel had, comparing it to Song of Solomon is in fact helping me take more pleasure in this story.
Another interesting parallel I found between Wide Sargasso Sea and the Song of Solomon is the similarities in the way the narratives are given. In part 2 of Wide Sargasso Sea, we were pretty much only saw things from Rochester's perspective, who portrayed Antoinette pretty unsympathetically. I think this is the same way Ruth is being portrayed by Macon. She doesn't get to tell her side of the story just like Antoinette. Macon himself previously said "Little by little he remembered fewer and fewer of the details, until finally he had to imagine them, even fabricate them, guess what they must have been" (16). He seemed a little too eager to believe Ruth was sleeping with her own father, when the normal response in my opinion would be to try to deny it. I personally don't believe his story, and really dislike him because to me he seems abusive and dominating just like Rochester, especially when we find out what he forced Ruth to do to try to get her to miscarry. I like how you compare him to Rochester, because to me he really does seem like him. I also never really noticed how Christophine and Pilate are alike until you pointed it out. They both seem like the only ones in the novels that really know what they are doing.
ReplyDeleteI disagree with you that Macon is easier to sympathize with than Rochester, because like you said, Macon is physically abusive whereas Rochester is not. Yes, Rochester might abuse Antoinette mentally, playing mind games and sleeping with other women, but Antoinette doesn't treat him completely fairly, either. She doesn't give him the chance to trust her and to hear her side of the story because she never tells it to him, and she tries to play mind games to by giving him the love potion. In addition, at least Rochester tries to love Antoinette. Macon, on the other hand, simply marries Ruth for money and status, and then seemingly only stays in the marriage for the sake of appearance.
ReplyDeleteI agree with you as well-- I like Song of Solomon more than I liked Wide Sargasso Sea. It may be just the plot that interests me more, but I do think Ashley makes a very good point, and it makes me think of some things. We at first get Antoinette's narration, but once in part two we don't hear from her again until quite a while after, and this could prove for misunderstanding for the readers due to varied ideas from the narrator. In Song of Solomon, I've really enjoyed Morrison's way of describing scenes: first we hear just a quick summary of a scenario, and then later on we are provided with the full story (and sometimes even later we get another point of view). Reading the story in this way makes it pretty fun for me, as I am always wanting to read on to the next secret that is hinted at in the novel.
ReplyDelete