Thursday, September 19, 2013

Throwback Thursday

Often times, people form ideas and views of other people, places, and events that they have experienced in their lives. It can be very hard to accept that things, or sometimes one's self, are different, so people usually have a tough time coping. Richard had not seen Clarissa for some time before the beginning of Mrs. Dalloway, his only communication with her being letters sent between England and India. When Peter returns to London and visits Clarissa, they both have the realization that things have changed over the years since they last were together. Peter tries to hold on to his memory of the past, but at the same time he becomes more restless as he realizes that the present is different from the past.

"Here she is mending her dress; mending her dress as usual, he thought; here she's been sitting all the time I've been in India; mending her dress; playing about; going to parties; running to the House and back and all that, he thought, growing more and more irritated, more and more agitated," (40).

Peter has trouble with the recognition of change, not with Clarissa, but with himself. In Clarissa's eyes, Peter is still the same man she knew before he went to India -- playing with his pocket-knife, having a love affair with a younger woman -- but Peter thinks the contrary, that he has not remained the same, while Clarissa is stuck in the exact same life as before he left. This meeting is troublesome for both Clarissa and Peter because they both have been so occupied with the past and their notions of each other from their days in Bourton. This consumes their thoughts for the rest of the novel, the comparison of their former selves and their present selves, and it provides for tensions between them. Whether it is seeing someone from years ago or returning to a town you used to live in, it is always hard to grasp and accept that the present is not the same as the past and that over time things change.

3 comments:

  1. The sentence at the end where you said "returning to a town you used to live in" really struck me! It reminds me of you and your hometown in Connecticut. You could make a really interesting post using that personal connection with you and Peter.

    I think the point you bring up about Peter having trouble with Clarissa's view of him is really interesting. But is the example you gave about having a love affair really considered a love affair? He is in England to make arrangements so that he and his love interest can get married. To me, an affair is more of a temporary thing, and doesn't involve marriage.

    ReplyDelete
  2. The relationship between Clarissa and Peter is, of course, very complicated. The idea that Clarissa hasn't changed or that Peter has reminds me of that one panel presentation where they mentioned socialization. To me, Clarissa seems to have changed a lot since her days at Bourton, where she would read Shelley and Morris and vilify the institution of marriage with Sally. Her social environment has shaped her (and Sally too) into a "perfect hostess" and a perfect wife. A lot of the conflict between Peter and Clarissa comes from Peter recognizing Clarissa's true self and wishing that it would shine through her charming facade. Meanwhile, Clarissa sees Peter, who hasn't really changed since he ran off to India. Like I said, pretty complicated.

    ReplyDelete
  3. There's a strange and potent mix of emotions going on with Peter here, I think: on the one hand, he's struck by how little he sees of the "old Clarissa" in Mrs. Richard Dalloway, while at the same time, he feels a bit smug about the fact that she's turned out more or less as he'd predicted. Likewise, he seems to resent the implication that his success in life would be judged by the likes of the Dalloways, and yet at the same time he judges his own life harshly through their eyes. (Much as Clarissa judges herself through his.)

    His physical distance from England is indeed relevant here: he's both returning to a place and to people that have been living, day to day, without him. As with any emotionally charged return to a place, it's an eerie combination of familiarity and change that strikes him most. It's easy to understand why Peter's mind is so much on the past, why he's so emotionally volatile, on this particular day.

    ReplyDelete