Wednesday, November 13, 2013

The Irrationality of the Universe

The Stranger by Albert Camus is a provocative novel with two of its major themes being the absurdity of the world and the meaninglessness of human life. Both of these themes manifest themselves when the novel's main character, Meursault, is alone in his prison cell waiting to be executed for killing an innocent man. He expresses fear for the first time when his heart beat "leaps" as he thinks about his imminent death. However, soon after Meursault opens up to the reader, he ponders the following question: If you're going to die, what's it matter if it is now or in 20 years? This seems to help him calm down a bit but I found this part to the be the most disturbing passage in the book.
Meursault had some low moments in terms of his humanity (i.e. killing the Arab, failing to show grief at his mother's funeral, etc.) but the hopeless approach that he takes in dealing with death sentence takes the cake. With the other instances of Meursault's lack of compassion, I found that, as an optimistic person, I could form little excuses as to why he should be forgiven. However, when he started having depressing thoughts about the lack of meaning of human life, I became both sad for and angry at him. I was angry at him because I felt like he wasn't aware of the privelage that he had in his life and because he didn't seize the opportunities for a better life that were handed to him, such as marrying Marie. But then I realized that, in my opinion, life is worth living if you have goals and aspirations, something to work towards (sorry if this is really cheesy), and Meursault did not have any of those. This was where I became sad for him. He had dreams once upon a time but he decided that they were irrational and adopted this attitude that life isn't worth living.
I guess this part of the book unnerved me because I couldn't imagine how Meursault was feeling or why he was feeling that way. Camus's way of working the two ideas -- the absurdity of the world and the meaninglessness of human life -- into The Stranger really got under my skin and I haven't decided yet if I liked the provocation or not.

3 comments:

  1. The Absurd is definitely a divisive issue in critical analysis of The Stranger that I've encountered while researching. There seems to be a distinct split between essays that analyze the book under the assumption that the world has meaning and those that analyze the book in the context of Camus' philosophical ideas. I find the ones that assume there is meaning to be kind of annoying, partially because it seems to disregard a key theme of the book, but also because I really liked reading about Mersault/Camus' views. I suppose maybe there are three ways people could react to Mersault's meaninglessness: either they love it, they hate it, or they follow Mersault's line of thought and decide that it really doesn't matter whether they like it or hate it.

    ReplyDelete
  2. What this reminded me of was Kathy in Never Let Me Go by Kazuo Ishiguro. (We read it in Utopias last year. I highly recommend it.) Basically the main character, in a hopeless situation herself, philosophizes about her purpose in life, and what the difference is between dying young and dying old, because all are working toward the same thing. But in that book, she has a reason to think that, because her situation is truly unfortunate. So I totally get what you mean about being unnerved by Meursault's lack of goals. Because while I was reading, I could only connect Meursault to Kathy and the free-range chickens debate.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I'm not sure I agree that Meursault concludes that "life isn't worth living," but maybe that he comes to realize that this "worth" is only something *he* brings to it himself, and the value of life is in no way guaranteed metaphysically--the "universe" remains indifferent. But from his jail cell, the simple pleasures life offers become intensely attractive to Meursault. He acknowledges that whether he experiences these pleasures or not doesn't much matter, from the point of view of the universe (or even anyone else--he expects to be forgotten)--they don't "mean" anything. And you're right that he distinctly lacks ambition. But in that lack of ambition I see a surprising ability to simply *be*, and to find pleasure in simple things like the sea or a cup of coffee or jumping on the back of a moving truck with a buddy from work. Ambition can be seen instead as a form of restlessness or perpetual dissatisfaction, of always wanting something more, or "wishing," as Meursault might put it. Maybe there's nothing *wrong* with that, but it doesn't make anything any more "meaningful."

    ReplyDelete