Wednesday, September 25, 2013

A Character Smoothie

We talked in class about the portrayal of various characters from Mrs. Dalloway in the movie "The Hours." There are a lot of characters who could potentially be Richard Brown, the suicidal writer from the movie. It is only natural to immediately assosicate him with Septimus who is also a suicidal writer who experiences hallucinations and heras voices. They both had traumatizing pasts, Septimus experiencing the war first-hand and Richard being deserted by his mother at a young age, and the ghosts of their pasts still haunt them.
However, another one of my earlier ideas was that Richard could be Peter Walsh because he and Clarissa had a previous romantic relathionship. Upon closer inspection, I changed my mind and decided Richard was more like Sally Seaton. In Mrs. Dalloway, we learn about when Sally and Clariss shared a kiss in their youth, and how that kiss still lingers in Clarissa's mind. However, they both ended up marrying men rather than exploring the possibility of being with someone of the same gender. Similarly, the Clarissa and the Richard from "The Hours" had a spark between them years ago, and they also ended up having different sexual orientations, shown by Clarissa being with Sally and Richard's previous relationship with Luis Waters.
One thing that is different, however, about Richard Brown and Sally Seaton is that Richard still thinks about his past romance with Clarissa Vaughan, even in the last moments of his life, while, to the best of our knowledge, Sally did not dwell on her romance with Clarissa Dalloway. This aspect proposes the idea that Clarissa Dalloway and Richard Brown are more similar than it originally seems. Clarissa and Richard both are haunted by the past, and Clarissa was supposed to kill herself before the Septimus character was brought into Mrs. Dalloway. Perhaps this is a way to portray a version of the novel where Clarissa does, in fact, commit suicide.
So who is Richard Brown? Is he Peter Walsh? Is he Sally Seaton? It is hard to tell, but I would say that he is a mixture of many main characters from the book, maybe even a character smoothie. He is involved in two of the three stories that "The Hours" follows and the reason for that is because he is such an important combination of people.

1 comment:

  1. "Character smoothie," I like that.
    I never noticed this similarity between Sally and Richard, probably because I just assumed Sally from the movie was that Sally. But how often do assumptions turn out to be correct? Now that I think about it, a possibly more subtle parallel is that they both have a significant effect on Clarissa, making her feel like someone not herself. Richard makes her feel like her life is important, that she's not just doing silly, pointless things. Sally gives her a similar feeling as they read about socialism and write letters, making Clarissa feel like she can make a difference. Both Clarissas are attracted to these people who make her life feel meaningful because they're so insecure about the possible pointlessness of their lives.

    ReplyDelete